Thursday, 6 May 2021

LO1: Developing and evaluating ideas (M1)

Mindmap of Ideas 1:


Mindmap of Ideas 2: Sports & Dogs

Mindmap of Ideas 3:




Summary: Sports / football magazine

I plan for the first magazine idea to be focusing on football in Sheffield, and Sheffield teams - this would appeal to the local area as they'd want to hear about what happens with their favourite teams & learn about the latest news. The target audience would be about 20-60, since football is a sport that appeals to all ages. However, the audience would be mostly male due to the connotations of football being a 'mans' sport. It could include interviews with footballers and local people who have their own stories and experiences to say, meaning that it would easily appeal to the locals.

One strength of this idea is that it easily fits to the brief since it would cater to a Sheffield audience, and it's a popular genre that could even appeal to people passing through the area. A second strength is that football has a lot of content to use - this can range from interviews, to drama, to upcoming games, and so forth. A third strength is that advertisements can easily be found because of the popularity of the genre, ensuring that it would get enough money to start and continue print production. 

One weakness of this idea is that it singles out a local female audience - women in Sheffield are less likely to be interested in Sheffield teams than the men would, so the paper would lose possible readers. Another weakness is that if there are last minute changes to planned events, the magazine would become outdated / inaccurate and could upset fans (the market is already saturated, so if the sports magazine were to have a bad reputation, it would fail). A final weakness is that getting interviews from celebrities and footballers would be difficult for a start-up magazine, as we wouldn't be able to offer monetary compensation.

Summary: Dogs / pet magazine

I plan for the second magazine idea to be focusing on dogs - specifically about how to look after your dog rather than information about breeds or sports. The target audience would be primarily parents who have children with dogs, since they would want to know how to help their family the best. The second audience would be children of these families, who would want to see the cute animals and help their parents. It could appeal to the Sheffield audience by using local areas that could be easily accessible from the city center, having Sheffield events mentioned, warnings about weather, etc.

One strength of the dog idea is that it can appeal to a good Sheffield audience - it could appeal to both men and women who have families and children (who have dogs), while also appealing to young people as they'd be interested in dogs. A lot of people in Sheffield have animals, such as spaniels. Another strength is that the dog magazine isn't incredibly saturated; it's easy to go out of the box and make a brand for it while also keeping to normal conventions. A third strength is that advertisers of dog toys, treats, beds, etc would be eager to advertise their products on our magazine (such as companies like Pets At Home) - and, to appeal to local Sheffield audiences, we could include local businesses in our advertising (although it may be too expensive for them).

One weakness is that the dog magazine market is very niche - the current successful dog magazines have been around for a long time or have enough backing behind them to keep going, so it'll be difficult to attract audiences. A second weakness is that there are very few celebrities related to dogs and our genre, so we won't be able to have many interviews unless they're from Sheffield locals (who could be difficult to find). A third weakness is that content for dog magazines would be difficult to find, since more and more information would have to be found each issue, which means we'd have to put in a lot of effort to keep it engaging and interesting for the audience.

No comments:

Post a Comment

LO1: Production documents (P1)

I plan to use a dog theme for my magazine - including how to look after dogs in the home and where to walk them. I have chosen this idea bec...